The series revolves around The Professor, Scotty MacProfessor, Col - The Adventurer and Chuck, The Projectionist who are trapped in an alternate universe. The only way back home is to screen and present a certain old horror movie, but which one. The movie vault will only allow one movie per week to be taken out. Each episode also includes Witch Cinders' Creepy Commercials, as well as Horror Host Tome - which a different horror host is presented. Special guests, and news reports are also shown.